GOP drops health care, pension change push amid protest

Detroit News, December 6, 2016

Lansing — Michigan’s Republican-led Legislature will not vote this year on controversial plans to limit retiree health care benefits for local government employees or close the state’s teacher pension system to new hires.

As police and firefighters descended on the Capitol Tuesday morning in protest, House Speaker Kevin Cotter confirmed he would not push for a vote on the bulk of the retiree health care package during the “lame-duck” session.

Cotter, who will be forced out of office at the end of the year due to term limits, said the debate deserved more time but had already helped “shine the light” on unfunded liabilities that threaten local government budgets across the state.

“The problem is very real, and it’s not going to go away,” said Cotter, R-Mount Pleasant. “It’s only going to get worse.”

With less than two weeks left on the legislative calendar, Senate Majority Leader Arlan Meekhof is also dropping his push to vote on bills that would move all new teachers into 401(k)-style retirement plans, a spokeswoman confirmed.

Meekhof, R-West Olive, delayed a planned vote last week after Gov. Rick Snyder’s administration raised alarms over “transition” costs associated with the proposal to end traditional and hybrid pension options for new teachers.

“Members of the caucus would like more time to review the policy as proposed, more time to review the numbers and to get a better understanding of the costs associated with a migration and the long-term savings opportunity,” Meekhof spokeswoman Amber McCann said.

She predicted legislators will continue to discuss teacher pension reform in the new two-year session that starts in January, “but it’s just not going to be tackled in lame-duck.”

Educators and public school groups, who argued the pension legislation would make the teaching profession less attractive to young people, celebrated news the package had stalled out.

“This proposal, if passed, would have resulted in layoffs, overcrowded classrooms and school closures, and could have even pushed schools to the brink of bankruptcy,” said Robert D. Livernois, Superintendent of Warren Consolidated Schools.

The House Committee on Local Government was scheduled to discuss the local government retiree health care proposal Tuesday morning, but 12 of the 13 bills were abruptly dropped from the schedule, effectively tabling the package for the year.

“I applaud the speaker for beginning this difficult conversation, but I think it’s more appropriate to tackle the issue in full in an upcoming term when all voices can be heard,” said Rep. Lee Chatfiled, R-Levering, who chairs the committee.

The legislation was designed to prohibit local governments from promising retiree health care coverage to new hires, instead giving them the option to contribute to a tax-deferred Health Savings Account employees could use on their own. It also would also force many current local government employees and retirees to pay for at least 20 percent of their own post-employment health care benefits.

Critics said the health care proposal could have been devastating for retirees living on fixed incomes, and its introduction prompted intense backlash from public safety personnel.

Firefighters gathered on the Capitol lawn Tuesday said it would have added another cut to the laundry list of concessions first responders have made in the last decade.

Mark Docherty, president of the Michigan Professional Fire Fighters Union, said he hopes legislators “take a more responsible” approach to unfunded health care liabilities next year.

“I’m glad they came to their senses,” he said.

Docherty, who represents roughly 5,000 firefighters in 130 Michigan communities, said the plan that stalled Tuesday would have hurt communities that already have cost-saving plans in place. Firefighter recruitment is already down, he said.

“I believe it is from all these attacks through the years,” Docherty said.

Kevin Kukla, 49, has been a firefighter in Harrison Township for 20 years. He and coworker Matt Czarnecki, 34, said this cutback would have affected firefighters and police officers most, because they typically retire sooner because of the toll the job takes on their bodies.

“When you’re already down to the bone, there’s nothing left,” Czarnecki said.

Kukla called Tuesday’s tabling a small victory.

“We want to get everyone at the table ... and have a conversation,” Kukla said.

The men warned that further cuts would continue to discourage people from becoming first responders.

“Why take the job with all that stress” Czarnecki said.

Cotter and others pushing the legislation said the state must address massive unfunded liabilities in order to help local governments avoid financial collapse or bankruptcy, which could lead to even steeper retiree cuts.

“Our mission is to make sure people get the benefits. That’s why we’re taking on this task,” said Rep. Dan Lauwers, R-Brockway. “If we continue to ignore the information and the situation that’s before us, it’s pretty likely that somebody’s going to get left without benefits.”

Lauwers sponsored a standalone bill that would increase reporting requirements for local governments to help the state understand the magnitude of the unfunded liabilities they face.

The proposal, which was the only measure considered and approved in committee on Tuesday, would require retirement systems to submit annual reports to the state Treasury, which would have to post data online. Local governments with retiree health care systems or pensions funded at less than 60 percent would have to document online steps it was taking to address the unfunded liabilities.

“We’re simply asking people to bring forward their information,” Lauwers said.

Democrats, who have acknowledged unfunded liabilities are an issue worth discussing, celebrated Cotter’s decision to drop the bulk of the retiree health care proposal for the year.

“It’s encouraging Republicans have come to their senses, at least for now, in backing away from hurting those who put their lives on the line every day to protect citizens,” said House Minority Leader Tim Greimel, D-Auburn Hills. “They put their lives on the line every day to protect us, the least we can do is make sure they have quality and affordable health care when they retire.”


December 2, 2016

Brothers and Sisters,

As you know, the Michigan FOP has been working hard on the pending lame duck legislation and contrary to what others are reporting, opposition testimony was taken in the local government committee yesterday, and the FOP was the only police group present to speak in opposition.

As of today, the bills continue to sit in the House Local Government Committee with another hearing scheduled for early next week. The FOP will once again be present.

Leaders from Michigan’s top public safety groups today also announced a Dec. 5th media roundtable at Michigan’s Capitol to discuss the ways in which state lawmakers’ proposed changes to pensions and retiree healthcare will dramatically impact current and former public safety professionals.

“The media recently has put a strong focus on how public employee pension changes will affect teachers, but the fact is, these changes also will hurt law enforcement, firefighters and emergency responders,” said Robert Stevenson, Executive Director, Michigan Association of Chiefs of Police. “Everyone understands that the state’s budget needs to be prudent. But we cannot stand by while lawmakers short-change the people who spent their careers laying their lives on the line to keep our communities safe.”

Roundtable representatives will include the Deputy Sheriffs Association of Michigan, Fraternal Order of Police, Michigan Association of Chiefs of Police, Michigan Association of Fire Chiefs, Michigan Association of Police Organizations, Michigan Fire Service Instructors Association, Michigan Professional Fire Fighters Union, Michigan Sheriffs Association, Michigan State Troopers Association, Police Officers Association of Michigan and Prosecuting Attorneys Association of Michigan.
The round table will take place on Monday at the State Capitol. We will provide you with an update following that.

In the meantime, continue to contact your local legislators and encourage them to vote NO on House Bill 6074. A list of legislators and how to local yours is on our website at
On Tues, Dec 6th we are planning on holding a rally with other organizations on the Capitol steps at 9:00 am. We are looking for involvement from off duty officers as well as retired members. Any assistance with this would appreciated. We will update on Monday after the round table for a location to possibly meet prior to the rally.


Joe Adams
State Lodge President

November 30, 2016


A few minutes ago, as expected, a package of 13 bills were introduced in the State House in Lansing, House Bill 6074-6086.

The main bill is HB 6074. A link can for the bill is

What the bill says:


If you’ve already retired, the City shall not pay more than 80% of your health care benefit. If you are already eligible for Medicare, the City shall not pay more than 80% of the annual cost of the health care benefit that is supplemental to Medicare.

If you’re currently working, no change while you’re working, however, the 80% cap on health care benefit applies immediately upon retirement.

Please continue to contact your State Representatives and State Senators and urge them to VOTE NO on House Bill 6074. A link to your reps can be found HERE.


November 29, 2016


Brothers & Sisters,

The Legislative Committee, our staff, and our lobbyist has been working diligently on the pending issues before us in the lame duck session. Tonight we learn that bills are going to be introduced tomorrow. We don't have all the details yet, but, this will effect not only new hires, but, those currently working and even worse, those who have already retired. We will post the details as we get them, but, in the meantime, we urge you to reach out to your ...legislators and tell them that lame duck is not the time to take up this kind of issue and leave public employee health care alone!

To find your representatives and a complete list of contact info, click here.


Joe Adams
State Lodge President